Stellenbosch versus Franschhoek: Who wins the battle in the Cape Winelands?

In a Nutshell

If you’re planning a trip to South Africa’s Cape Winelands , you’ll likely find yourself torn between Stellenbosch versus Franschhoek. Both towns are beautiful, brimming with fine wine and fabulous food, but each offers a very different flavour: Stellenbosch is historic, lively, and versatile; Franschhoek is romantic, a little more boutique, and more compact. Here’s how to choose between them.

Stellenbosch versus Franschhoek: The Cape Winelands Face-Off

Writing a comparison between Stellenbosch and Franschhoek can feel a little risky. Furious hoteliers and loyal fans of each town will tell you their town is best and accuse me of bias. But visitors often ask us this question so let’s be brave and make this comparison. I’ll take a clear-eyed look at both, as someone who’s lived in South Africa for three decades and spent countless weekends exploring the vineyards, restaurants, and mountain roads of the Cape Winelands.

The Essence of Each Town

Originally, I come from the Cotswolds in England where we have what we nicknamed “show villages”. Bourton on the Water is a classic example. It is immensely picturesque with a babbling brook running through, charming little shops and art galleries and a wide village green bordered by handsome golden-stoned Cotswold ‘cottages’. Its obvious appeal led to coach loads of tourists wanting to spend their money. Lovely but expensive shops sprang up to lighten the weight of the punters’ wallets. There is nothing wrong with Bourton on the Water; it’s just that it is somewhat unreal. Real villages don’t look like that.

To my mind, there is something similar about Franschhoek. Yes, it’s a very pretty little town in a gorgeous valley surrounded by towering mountains, with a central street crammed with chichi little shops and the ubiquitous art galleries. There are no end of charming little places to eat, many alfresco. It is almost the good life personified. So I can see its obvious appeal to the visitor. But is it real? (And – more importantly – does that even matter? – you may ask)

Whereas Stellenbosch is South Africa’s second-oldest town (founded in 1679) and arguably its most beautiful. Oak-lined streets, Cape Dutch architecture in spades, a thriving university, and more than 100 nearby wine estates make it a vibrant mix of history and modern life.

Stellenbosch

The Cape Governor, Simon van der Stel, visited the Eerste River Valley in 1679 and decided this was the perfect place to establish farms to feed the restocking needs of the ships passing through Cape Town on their way from Europe to the Dutch East Indies (now Malaysia).

This charming town offers an array of oak-lined streets with picturesque Cape Dutch houses with their characteristic white-washed walls, and ancient water furrows lining the streets. As with Franschhoek there are plenty of shops, bistros and yes, art galleries.

Why You’ll Love It

• Authentic local life: Stellenbosch isn’t just for tourists — it’s a living town with students, professionals, and families. Expect bustling cafés, diverse restaurants, and genuine character.
• But given that the town is not reliant on tourists, the range and prices are wider and more eclectic.
• Wine heritage: Huge number of wine estates, many with excellent restaurants for lunchtime stops. Many of the good wine estates are in the Stellenbosch valley given its slightly milder climate. Think iconic wine estates such as Kanonkop, Rustenberg, Thelema, and Jordan.
• The Vine Hopper offers an easy way to tour some of the wine estates without needing to use your rental car (or take a guide).
• Fine dining: Several top-rated restaurants, including Rust en Vrede, Dusk, and Jordan, feature regularly at the top of our “Eat Out Awards.”
• Art & History: Visit the Rupert Museum (with one of the finest collections of South African art, theStellenbosch Village Museum, and nearbyEagle Encountersfor wildlife experiences.
• Bites & Sites Foodie walking tours through the town sampling South African delicacies
• Great for exploring: Stellenbosch’s more central location makes it an ideal base. As all the other Winelands town (Franschhoek, Paarl, and Somerset West) are within an easy 30-40 minutes’ drive.
• The only real University town in South Africa (with the well-regarded Stellenbosch University), and the sizeable student population lends a vibrancy and carefree air.
• Jonkershoek Nature Reserve, on the edge of the town, offers a range of hikes, waterfalls, and picnic spots amid breath-taking mountain scenery.

Good to Know

• It’s a town, not a village so expect some traffic and limited parking in the historic centre. You may have to park further away and walk a few hundred metres…
• The outskirts include light industry, so first impressions on approach may not reflect its central charm. (The easy analogy here is Oxford in England versus Cambridge.)

Stellenbosch Hotels

From luxury icons like Lanzerac Hotel & Spa and Majeka House, to central boutique hotels such as Oude Werf and River Manor, Stellenbosch has options for every budget. Some are in town or easy walking distance away. Others are on the edge of town so you would need a rental car or have a private guide.

Franschhoek

The origins of this charming and beautifully situated village date back to 1688 when some of the French Huguenots fleeing religious persecution in Europe settled in the valley, then known as Elephants Corner. As the settlers increased, the elephants ceased their annual migration to the valley, which gradually became known as ”French Corner”, or ‘Franschhoek’ in Afrikaans. Its French Huguenot heritage still lingers in the names of its wine estates and its unmistakably charm.

Why You’ll Love It

• Scenic splendour: Franschhoek sits in a dramatic mountain valley, one of the most beautiful settings in the Cape Winelands.
• Easy to get around – is basically one long main street with secondary streets in a simple grid fashion. There are no real issues with parking though you might need to park one street back from the main road.
• Culinary capital: The town boasts a concentration of award-winning restaurants including La Petite Colombe, Epice, and Chef’s Warehouse at Maison.
• Compact charm: The main street is easily walkable, lined with cafés, boutiques, and art galleries . There are lovely street cafes and bistros where you can sit out and relax in the sunshine.
• The Wine Tram: A delightful hop-on-hop-off tram with several route that link several local wine estates in one day without the need to drive. All the better to enjoy the wine-tasting.
• As well as the wine estates to visit, there’s also the Franschhoek Motor Museum
• Cultural heritage: Founded by French Huguenots in 1688, its Gallic influence remains in the architecture, wine names, and annual Bastille Day celebrations.

Good to Know

• Franschhoek is smaller and more tourist-focused — boutique perfection but at boutique prices. (On the other hand, they are geared towards visitors so it’s all pretty slick.)
• Its location at the far end of the valley (north-eastern part of the Cape Winelands ) means a longer drive to other towns in the Winelands, or to Cape Town Airport.  This is not a major issue unless you are catching a morning flight. (You’d save yourselves an extra 30 to 40 minutes in bed if you base yourself in Stellenbosch.)
• Franschhoek is unashamedly a tourist town. Everything is orientated around wine-tasting or eating. This is not necessarily a bad thing. But if you also enjoy Cape Dutch architecture, history, museums, then Stellenbosch might be a better bet?

Franschhoek Hotels

Favourites include Franschhoek Country House, Avondrood Guesthouse, and the ultra-luxurious La Residence. Again a wealth of places to stay but mostly in the middle to upper to extremely expensive side. As with Stellenbosch, only some of these are within walking distance of the shops etc.

At a Glance: Stellenbosch vs Franschhoek

	Stellenbosch	Franschhoek
Vibe	Historic, lively, student energy	Intimate, romantic, French-inspired
Best for	Wine lovers, explorers, history buffs, foodies	Foodies, couples, art & design lovers
Dining	High-end restaurants & casual bistros	High-end, Michelin-style cuisine
Accessibility	Central in Winelands, closer to Cape Town	More remote, valley setting
Size & Feel	Larger, more local life	Smaller, curated, tourist-focused
Wine Estates	Huge array within 30 minutes	Smaller selection, but picture-perfect
Architecture & Culture	17th-century Cape Dutch heritage	Huguenot French history
Outdoor Options	Jonkershoek hiking, cycling, art walks, markets	Wine Tram, scenic drives

Other places to stay in the Cape Winelands

If you want to explore beyond the “big two”:

Paarl  – grand, historic estates and mountain views, less touristy.

Somerset West– closer to beaches and the Whale Coast, so great for a longer stay of 5-7 nights.

Or opt for a country-based hotel – such as Babylonstoren and Boschendal – for a private, countryside stay with farm-to-table dining. (Here it’s best if you have your own rental car or private guide for touring.)

The Verdict: Stellenbosch versus Franschhoek

There’s no clear winner — and that’s the beauty of it. It depends on what you like to do.

• Choose Stellenbosch if you like history, variety, and local buzz.
• Choose Franschhoek if you crave charm, gastronomy, and postcard-perfect scenery.

As you can see, I love Stellenbosch. I hate to think that Franschhoek is being chosen solely because it is better marketed (which it certainly is), as both have their charms.

 

Related Articles

Still torn between Stellenbosch’s heritage and Franschhoek’s charm?

Let us help you choose. At Cedarberg Africa, we make it effortless to plan your perfect Cape Winelands getaway:

1. Tell us what you love: food, wine, art, or scenery.
2.  We design your ideal itinerary, drawing on decades of first-hand experience in the Winelands.
3. You relax and sip the rewards: seamless arrangements, beautiful stays, and insider tips at no extra cost.

---

“Stellenbosch versus Franschhoek” was written by Kate from specialist safari operator Cedarberg Africa

Author Bio: Kate co-founded Cedarberg Africa in 1995 with her sister Ginny and has lived in South Africa for over 30 years. A long-time Winelands fan, she has personally explored its vineyards, valleys, and boutique hotels  from Stellenbosch’s lively streets to Franschhoek’s mountain cafés. Her team’s insider knowledge helps you experience South Africa’s wine country with depth, comfort, and local flair.